OutKast, “Chonkyfire”
The conclusion to the classic Aquemini, the record where OutKast fulfilled their promise and delivered one of the greatest hip-hop records ever. That assertion is not diminished at all by the observation that it’s not entirely clear if it’s their best album. The number of artists who can make a legitimate claim to having made two all-time albums in their genre is a tiny number indeed.
James Brown, “The Payback”
I see what you’re doing shuffle, trying to slyly put forward a titan in a particular genre to imply that maybe there are lots of artists in the “two all-time albums” category. But here’s the thing: I don’t think it’s true of Brown. Obviously an incredible artist, and his work is foundational to funk and all. But his albums were a real mixed bag, with filler frequently padding things out. His live albums were generally his best work, because they tended to be greatest hits records. Or a comp like Star Time. But I don’t think it’s fair to include that in a greatest album discussion, so Brown kind of misses that criteria.
[Read More]